The Mystery Of Who Put Bella In The Wych Elm
On April 18, 1943, in the middle of World War II, four boys out hunting for bird eggs in Birmingham, England discovered a human skeleton inside the trunk of a hollowed out wych elm tree. Police were able to uncover an almost complete skeleton along with a gold ring and a few fragments of clothing. Forensic analysis estimated the body was female, around thirty-five-years-old, and had been dead for approximately eighteen months. There was no identification. Police checked with local dentists because the Jane Doe had extensive dental work done, but they were not able to find any matches. The Birmingham police had a mysterious Jane Doe cold case on their hands.
The case got even more mysterious when in the middle of the night someone painted a graffiti message on a wall in Birmingham that read: "Who put Bella down the wych elm?" Since 1943 the mysterious message has appeared several times around the Birmingham area. Because of this strange message police and the public assumed the Jane Doe was named Bella. But who was she? Who killed her? And who was leaving the graffiti messages about her?
In the early 1950's a local journalist wrote several articles about "Bella" hoping to spur someone into coming forward who could unlock the mystery. Soon a letter arrived at the newspaper. It was written by a woman who called herself "Anna". She said the victim was Dutch and had arrived illegally in England around 1941. The letter said the person responsible for killing "Bella" was insane and had since died. Authorities encouraged "Anna" to come forward. The journalist later claimed that "Anna" was actually a woman called Una Hainesworth. The journalist claims he was present when police interviewed Una. The journalist claims Una told them her husband, Jack Mossop, was responsible for killing "Bella" and putting her in the wych elm. Mossop went insane after the killing and died in a mental hospital. Not everyone was convinced that Una was telling the truth. The case remained open, so police must not have taken her story too seriously either.
There are many who believe "Bella" was a part of a German spy ring operating in Birmingham at that time. It was World War II and there were several munitions' factories in the area that German spies were reportedly interested in. One spy had allegedly been apprehended near Birmingham, so this theory seemed plausible to a lot of people. They speculate this is why no one reported her missing or claimed her remains. There are others who think the death of "Bella" was the work of witchcraft. Putting a body in a tree trunk was allegedly a common practice in witchcraft.
Who wrote the mysterious graffiti messages? Was it "Bella's" killer? Was it someone who knew her and knew what happened to her but couldn't come forward? With the mystery still lingering in 2014 researchers at Queen Mary University in London used a probabilistic technique called a Bayesian Network to attempt to shed new light on the decades old case. They concluded there was a 99% likelihood that her death was criminal and a 97% likelihood that "Bella" was not British. They found a 33% chance that Jack Mossop killed her and a 25% chance that "Bella" was a spy. In 2018 new technology helped produce a photograph of "Bella", finally giving her a face to go with the name. The image was released hoping someone would come forward who might have known her. As of this writing no one has claimed her. The mystery of who put Bella in the wych elm remains.